Visual novels like Creepy Dates
Last updated:
Creepy Dates sits at a specific intersection: horror dating sim, dark comedy, heavy branching, made by one person, free. Which recommendation fits depends on which of those you actually came for, so this page is organised by that rather than as a ranked list.
The nearest thing to more Creepy Dates is another run through it. Six routes exist and most players only see one or two.
The shortlist: games actually comparable to Creepy Dates
Broadening out from the one comparison most pages make, these are the games that genuinely overlap with what Creepy Dates is — dating wrapped in horror, with real branching:
| Game | What you romance | Why it fits |
|---|---|---|
| Hooked on You: A Dead by Daylight Dating Sim | Horror-franchise killers | The mainstream "date the slasher" pitch — and its spin the bottle is an actual aimable minigame, unlike the scripted scene in Creepy Dates. |
| Doki Doki Literature Club | Cute-on-the-surface club members | Free visual novel where the dating-sim shell hides psychological horror — the closest match on price and on "cute surface, dark core". |
| Sucker for Love: First Date | Eldritch gods | Polished cosmic-horror rom-com that matches Creepy Dates' dark-comedy tone. |
| Monster Prom | Monsters, competitively | Multiplayer monster dating sim with stat-based branching — the match if replay value is what you want. |
| Homicipher | Monsters, through language | Horror adventure where you decipher what monsters say in order to romance them; the darkest tone of the bunch. |
| A Date with Death | The Grim Reaper | Free, short visual novel — the closest match to the length of one Creepy Dates route. |
Prices and platform lists change, so check each store page — but every game above is real, released, and matches at least one of Creepy Dates' three draws.
If you came for the killer-dating premise
Hooked on You in the table above is the mainstream version of the pitch. Beyond the list, itch.io's own horror and dating sim tags are more useful than any article: the free fan-game scene there is exactly where Creepy Dates came from, and browsing by tag surfaces games too new or too small to appear in roundups.
If you came for the creepypasta cast
The creepypasta fangame scene is overwhelmingly on itch.io and is dominated by small solo projects. Hahadit's own Jeff the Killer dress-up game is the closest match in art style, since it is by the same artist.
Worth setting expectations: there is no other creepypasta dating sim with Creepy Dates' scope. That is a large part of why it gets the attention it does, and why its search results are so heavily targeted by low-quality copycat sites.
If you came for the branching and the choices
Creepy Dates gates content on where you go rather than only on what you say — the Toby encounter being the clearest case. If that is the appeal, look for visual novels built in Ren'Py with exploration layers rather than pure dialogue trees; itch.io's visual novel tag filtered to free releases is the most productive way to find them.
What Creepy Dates does that these games don't
A fair comparison needs the other side of the ledger. Creepy Dates' specific mix, all confirmed on this site's other pages:
- Gating by where you go, not what you say. The Toby encounter is decided by room order — most dialogue-tree visual novels have nothing equivalent.
- A jealousy system with no visible meter. Chapter 3 states outright that affection spread changes how possessive characters treat you, and the game never shows a number.
- Chapters shipped as free add-ons to one build, with saves carried across — not sequels, not paid DLC.
- Four languages — Spanish, English, Russian and Portuguese — from a solo developer who also draws every sprite.
If any of those is the thing you actually liked, the honest answer is that no game on this page replicates all of it — which is why replays are the real "similar games" list here. The six routes have distinct scenes most players never see on a first run.
If you are just waiting for Chapter 4
Two things are worth doing first:
- Follow the game on itch.io. Chapter 3's date came via a devlog, so that is where Chapter 4's will land too. See the Chapter 4 status page.
- Do a concentrated-affection run. If your first playthrough spread affection around, a focused one plays noticeably differently — the jealousy dialogue on the Slenderman route in particular.
Frequently asked questions
What visual novels are similar to Creepy Dates?
Hooked on You: A Dead by Daylight Dating Sim is the closest mainstream comparison; Doki Doki Literature Club, Sucker for Love, Monster Prom, Homicipher and A Date with Death each match a different side of it. For free indie equivalents, itch.io's horror and dating sim tags are the most productive place to browse.
Is there another creepypasta dating sim like this?
Nothing at a comparable scope. The creepypasta fangame scene is mostly small solo projects on itch.io, including Hahadit's own Jeff the Killer dress-up game.
Are there free games like Creepy Dates?
Yes — Doki Doki Literature Club and A Date with Death are both free, and itch.io's horror and dating sim tags filter to free releases if you want more in the same scene Creepy Dates came from.
What should I play while waiting for Chapter 4?
Replay Creepy Dates on a different route. There are six, and most players finish only one or two on a first playthrough.
Keep reading
Creepy Dates Chapter 4 release date
25 October, announced by Hahadit on Tumblr.
Every route and character in Creepy Dates
The six playable routes, plus the characters who appear without one.
Creepy Dates: game facts, developer and community
Who made it, what it runs on, and where the real community is.
Creepy Dates on itch.io: the official source and file sizes
The only official source, with file sizes and install notes.